Shopify Long Tail SEO: How to Win When Big Brands Own Page One

What do you need help with?

Select all that apply

What are your goals?

Select all that apply

Please let us know your company website URL

We’re putting your marketing plan & pricing options together. Who can we send them to?

Watch on YouTube and use the comments for any questions – I reply to every one!

If your Shopify store is getting outranked by Amazon, this is not a failure.

It is the default.

Search your main category keyword.

Look at page one.

Amazon. eBay. Big brands with marketing teams larger than your entire company.

If your plan is still to outrank them eventually, you are doing Shopify SEO the hard way.

And the expensive way.

Big brands owning page one is not the real problem.

Trying to beat them at their own game is.

Why head terms are a losing battle early on

Most Shopify brands start in the same place.

They search the main category keyword.

Page one is already taken.

Not because your product is bad.

Not because your site is broken.

But because those brands have authority built over years.

Sometimes decades.

Trying to outrank that directly is slow, expensive, and usually frustrating.

Often accompanied by advice to just create better content.

Which is not very helpful.

Unless you are already a category leader, Shopify SEO rarely starts with head terms.

What long tail keywords actually are

Long tail keywords are not obscure.

They are specific.

They usually show up around use cases.

Problems. Comparisons. Alternatives.

These are not huge volume searches.

They are the searches people make once they have stopped browsing and started deciding.

Individually they look small.

Collectively they make up a large share of real demand.

They are usually less competitive.

And far more honest about intent.

Why long tail works so well for Shopify

Long tail works for a few very boring reasons.

There is less competition.

The intent is clearer.

Relevance matters more than raw authority.

You do not need Amazon-level backlinks to rank for a specific problem or comparison.

Which is fortunate.

Because you do not have Amazon’s budget either.

Long tail traffic also converts better.

The searcher is not browsing.

They are selecting.

This is the realistic path to organic growth for challenger brands.

How to spot long tail queries that actually matter

The trick is not volume.

It is intent.

You are looking for searches that sound like decisions.

Best product for a specific use case.

Product for a specific problem.

Product versus product.

Alternative to a known brand.

Product for a specific audience.

If the search sounds like someone is about to choose, it usually is.

Where the best long tail ideas come from

Most good long tail ideas are not hidden.

They are sitting in plain sight.

Google autocomplete.

Related searches.

People Also Ask.

Competitor comparison pages and guides.

Keyword tools filtered by intent words like best, for, versus, alternative.

Reddit threads and community discussions.

Customer support tickets.

On-site search terms.

Especially the last two.

Customers are usually far clearer than marketers.

If people are typing it when they are close to buying, it is usually worth building for.

Content that actually ranks and converts

Long tail content works when the format matches the intent.

Comparisons and alternatives for shoppers choosing between options.

Use case guides for problem-led searches.

Buyer guides for decision support.

FAQs to remove objections.

Collection or category pages targeting specific subsets.

Not one generic page trying to do everything.

The rule is simple.

Answer the exact query.

Be specific.

Show the fit.

Make the next step obvious.

The takeaway

If your main keywords are dominated by big brands, long tail SEO is how you start winning without waiting years.

Go after high intent searches first.

Comparisons. Use cases. Problems. Alternatives.

They convert.

They drive revenue.

And they build the depth and authority Google actually trusts.

Once your brand authority grows, head terms stop being a pipe dream.

They become the next step.

Want help competing with big brands? Check out our Shopify SEO service to see how we could help you!

Subscribe to Our Brand Authority Blog

Get a front-row seat to the strategies we use to help pet, wellness, and lifestyle brands build authority that ranks. Each week, our team drops practical, creative, and sometimes dangerously effective SEO and Digital PR insights. Side effects may include spontaneous light-bulb moments and excessive bragging in marketing meetings.

Share Now

Start Increasing Your Organic Traffic Today!

The 2025 Organic Search Benchmark Report for Pet Brands

See which pet brands are leading and which are lagging in Organic & AI Search. This report uncovers the reasons behind the gap—and highlights where the growth opportunities lie.